What is the frequency of site redesign?
The Optimal Case
Assuming you’ve built a good looking site with solid content based on compliant code, how often do you redesign? There are many other factors involved, such as whether you are a design fanatic with a personal blog or a major corporation with a company site, but assuming that you were a company that didn’t enjoy redesigning, how often would a site redesign be necessary?
Chances are that the visual appearance of such a well constructed site would have to be updated to be current with modern design trends every 4 or 5 years. The hope is that only the visual appearance would be changed—the content would still be useful and the markup would still be valid.
Sub-par Cases
There are, of course, an infinite number of sub-par cases. Many of these involve low quality, inane, or incorrect content, invalid or inaccessible markup, all manner of proprietary scripts and features, or management whims.
It’s conceivable that, under such conditions, a site could be so bad as to force a redesign as often as every 9 to 12 months and could use a redesign every single month until someone finally got it right.
The Costs Involved
Clearly, redesigns that are 5 times as frequent and that require much more effort to perform are more than 5 times as expensive. Even if redesigns were skipped and the site limped along for five years in a broken state, the lost revenues would far exceed the cost of developing a better site. It would therefore be worth at least 5 times the up-front money to get a site right the first time.
The Smart But Realistic Case
The smartest thing to do, then, would obviously be to shoot for the optimal redesign case. Do everything you can to build a site that will require very little maintenance and virtually no redesigning for 4 years or more. Skimping on site design isn’t really a good idea—solid design may (or may not) cost you, but it will pay itself back in the end, whereas skimping will only hit you with redesign fees over and over.
Make sure to do your research—many fantastic, cutting-edge firms charge about the same as crappy, out-of-date firms in order to compete. You may need to learn a little bit about site design and web standards in order to distinguish between different firms. If you are a developer, be or become one of those good firms that builds sites the right way!
Because doo doo happens, however, be prepared for changes that can take place. If you’ve properly separated design from content, it should be much easier to make updates to layout and design than it would be otherwise.
What other tactics do you know of to mitigate the impact of or to remove the need for frequent site redesigns?